This chapter is a letter written by Dr. Verghese Kurien to his grandson Siddharth in 2005. It is a reflection on life, values, choices, and the importance of service to society. The chapter teaches students about meaningful communication, moral values, and the purpose of life through the experiences of the founder of the White Revolution in India.
---
**Genre:** Personal Letter / Memoir
**Author:** Dr. Verghese Kurien (1921-2012)
**Recipient:** His grandson, Siddharth
**Time Period:** Written in 2005, reflecting on work done since India's independence
**Context:** Dr. Kurien is sharing his life philosophy and values with the next generation
**Key Information:**
---
**Definition:** The author contrasts **fleeting communication** (telephone calls that give momentary joy) with **lasting communication** (written letters that can be treasured and re-read).
**Key Concepts:**
**Why Writing is Superior:**
**Textual Evidence:**
"Writing—even if it is a letter—not only conveys our present concerns and views of the events taking place around us but it becomes a possession that can be treasured and re-read over the years, with great, abiding pleasure."
**Exam Tip:** This comparison is crucial for understanding the author's purpose in writing the letter instead of calling his grandson.
---
**Historical Context:** Dr. Kurien began his work immediately after India became independent in 1947.
**The Dream of Independent India:**
The author envisioned a nation where:
**Foremost:** Leading or most important
**The Author's Realization:**
Dr. Kurien realized that **choosing one path in life means abandoning other possibilities**. This is an important life lesson about commitment and sacrifice.
**Exam Important Point:** Understand that the author made a conscious choice to serve farmers rather than pursue more lucrative careers in metallurgy, the army, or the USA.
---
**Alternative Careers the Author Could Have Pursued:**
1. **Metallurgy:** Could have become the Chief Executive of a large company
2. **Military Service:** Could have received a commission in the Indian Army and retired as a general
3. **Migration to USA:** Could have become a successful Non-Resident Indian (NRI)
**Why He Chose Service in Anand:**
"Yet, I chose none of these because somewhere, deep down, I knew I could make a more meaningful contribution by working here in Anand, Gujarat."
**Key Life Lesson:** Meaningful contribution and purpose are more valuable than wealth, power, or status.
**The Transformation:**
"This transformation took place within me fifty years ago, when I agreed to work for a small cooperative of dairy farmers who were trying to gain control over their lives."
**Cooperative:** An organization owned and controlled by its members (farmers) working together for mutual benefit. This became the foundation of the White Revolution in India (Amul—Anand Milk Union Limited).
---
**The Grandmother's Choice:**
**Ardently:** In a way that shows strong feelings; with passion and enthusiasm
"Your grandmother too made an important choice. She knew, in those days, life in Anand could not offer even the simple comforts that we take for granted today. However, she ardently supported my choice to live and work in Anand."
**What This Reveals:**
**Poise:** Calm and confident manner; dignified composure
**Impact of Family Support:**
"That choice of your grandmother to stand by me has given me an everlasting strength, always ensuring that I shouldered my responsibilities with poise."
**Exam Insight:** Family support is crucial in pursuing meaningful life goals. The grandmother is presented as an equal contributor to the author's success.
---
**Values Inherited:**
Dr. Kurien emphasizes that his contributions were possible because he "consistently adhered to certain values":
**Integrity: The Most Important Value**
**Integrity:** Honest and strong moral principles; quality of being truthful and having strong ethics
"I have often spoken of integrity as the most important of these values, realizing that integrity—and personal integrity, at that—is being honest to yourself."
**The Logic of Integrity:**
"If you are always honest to yourself, it does not take much effort in always being honest with others."
**Exam Point:** This is a crucial philosophical statement—personal integrity leads to integrity in all external dealings.
---
**Life as a Privilege:**
"I have also learnt what I am sure you, too, will find out some day. Life is a privilege and to waste it would be wrong."
**Three Responsibilities in Life:**
1. **Accept responsibility for yourself:** Take ownership of your actions and decisions
2. **Use your talents to the best of your ability:** Utilize the gifts and strengths you possess
3. **Contribute somehow to the common good:** Give back to society in meaningful ways
**Common Good Manifests in Many Forms:**
**Redefining Failure:**
"I hope that you, too, will discover, as I did, that failure is not about not succeeding. Rather, it is about not putting in your best effort and not contributing, however modestly, to the common good."
**Key Understanding:** Success is measured not by outcomes alone but by the effort invested and contribution made. Failure is the absence of genuine effort.
---
**The Happiness Paradox:**
"In life you, too, will discover as I did, that anything can go wrong at any time and mostly does. Yet, there is little correlation between the circumstances of people's lives and how happy they are."
**Correlation:** A connection or relationship between two or more things. Here, the author says that external circumstances don't necessarily determine happiness.
**The Comparison Trap:**
"Most of us compare ourselves with someone we think is happier—a relative, an acquaintance, or often, someone we barely know. But when we start looking closely we realise that what we saw were only images of perfection."
**Lesson:** Comparing our lives to others' perceived happiness leads to discontent. What we see is often only a façade.
**True Contentment:**
"And that will help us understand and cherish what we have, rather than what we don't have."
**Exam Insight:** This teaches students about gratitude, self-awareness, and the danger of social comparison—relevant to modern times with social media.
---
**Historical Context:**
Dr. Kurien received the Padma Vibhushan (one of India's highest civilian awards) in 1999 from the President of India.
**The Medal Incident:**
When young Siddharth saw the medal and asked to keep it, both the author and grandmother responded with a profound lesson:
"We told you that of course, this medal was yours as much as it was mine but that you should not be satisfied in merely keeping my awards—the challenge before you was to earn your own reward for the work that you did in your lifetime."
**Life Lesson:** Each generation must earn its own recognition through honest work. Inherited accolades have no value; personal achievement is what matters.
---
**Three Conditions for Living Fully:**
1. **Be brave enough to love:** Have courage to give and receive love
2. **Be strong enough to rejoice in another's happiness:** Celebrate others' success without jealousy
3. **Be wise enough to know that there is enough to go around for all:** Understand the principle of abundance and non-scarcity
**Quote:** "And in the end, if we are brave enough to love, strong enough to rejoice in another's happiness and wise enough to know that there is enough to go around for all, then we would have lived our lives to the fullest."
**True Rewards:**
"Remember, rewards that come to you then are the only true rewards for a life well-spent."
---
**Definition:**
**Identifying from the Text:**
**FACTS:**
**OPINIONS:**
**Exam Strategy:** Look for personal pronouns ("I believe," "I think"), subjective adjectives ("beautiful," "meaningful"), and statements that reflect values rather than facts.
---
**1. Contrast/Antithesis:**
The author contrasts different forms of communication:
**Purpose:** To emphasize the superiority of written communication and its lasting impact.
**2. Metaphor:**
"A series of events swept me along and put me in a certain time with a choice that would transform my life."
**Explanation:** Life circumstances are compared to a sweeping force, suggesting that events carry us forward with power and momentum.
**3. Alliteration:**
"free from hunger and poverty" — Repeated 'f' sound
"contribution" and "common good" — Repeated 'c' sound
**4. Personification:**
The author gives life-like qualities to abstract concepts:
**5. Rhetorical Questions:**
"When did I write to you last? I have trouble even remembering!"
**Purpose:** Creates intimacy and engages the reader in reflection.
**6. Repetition:**
"You will then discover... you may want to share... you will pick up... you, too, will discover"
**Purpose:** Emphasizes the cyclical nature of generational learning and values.
**7. Symbolism:**
---
**Key Vocabulary with Synonyms:**
| Word | Definition | Synonym |
|------|-----------|---------|
| Addicted | Dependent on something | Dependent, Hooked |
| Fleeting | Momentary; lasting only a short time | Temporary, Brief, Transient |
| Abiding | Lasting; continuing for a long time | Enduring, Permanent, Lasting |
| Jottings | Brief notes; quick writings | Notes, Scribbles |
| Foremost | Leading; most important | Primary, Chief, First |
| Humility | Modesty; quality of being humble | Modesty, Meekness |
| Pursue | Follow; chase; engage in | Chase, Follow, Seek |
| Envisioned | Imagined or expected something in a particular way | Imagined, Pictured, Visualized |
| Ardently | With strong feelings; passionately | Passionately, Eagerly, Fervently |
| Poise | Calm and confident manner | Composure, Calmness, Balance |
| Adhered | Continued to support; stuck to | Followed, Observed, Maintained |
| Integrity | Honest and strong moral principles | Honesty, Morality, Virtue |
| Correlation | Connection between two or more things | Relationship, Connection, Link |
| Musings | Thoughts on something considered carefully | Thoughts, Reflections, Contemplations |
---
**Definition:**
Dashes are punctuation marks used to link words, numbers, or to create pauses in sentences. There are two main types.
**EN DASH (–)**
**Use:** Represents a span or range in numbers, dates, or time periods
**Examples:**
**Note:** No spaces around the en dash.
**EM DASH (—)**
**Use:** Adds extra information or shows a change in thought within a sentence
**Examples:**
(Additional information in the middle)
(Change in thought/clarification)
(Parenthetical information)
(Addition of new thought)
**Important Rules:**
---
**Understanding the Difference:**
These are commonly confused words that look or sound similar but have different meanings and uses.
**ITS vs. IT'S**
| Its | It's |
|-----|------|
| Possessive pronoun showing ownership | Contraction of "it is" or "it has" |
| "The dog wagged its tail" | "It's getting dark outside" |
| "The tree lost its leaves" | "It's been a long day" |
**YOUR vs. YOU'RE**
| Your | You're |
|-----|--------|
| Possessive pronoun; shows belonging | Contraction of "you are" |
| "Can I have one of your books?" | "You're going to love this book" |
| "Please bring your assignment" | "You're doing great work" |
**THEIR vs. THEY'RE**
| Their | They're |
|-------|---------|
| Possessive pronoun; shows ownership | Contraction of "they are" |
| "We should contact their manager" | "They're coming to the field trip" |
| "The team celebrated their victory" | "They're excited about the match" |
**Practice:**
1. "Please remember to bring **your** (your/you're) assignment book."
2. "The team celebrated **their** (their/they're) victory."
3. "**It's** (its/it's) important to stay hydrated."
4. "I can't believe **you're** (your/you're) going to the festival."
5. "The students said **they're** (they're/their) excited."
6. "The tree lost **its** (its/it's) leaves."
---
**Definition:** Prepositional phrases are groups of words that begin with a **preposition** and include a noun or pronoun as the **object of the preposition**. They provide information about time, place, manner, cause, direction, or relationship.
**Structure:** Preposition + (Adjectives) + Noun/Pronoun
**Examples from the Text:**
1. **In today's fast-paced world** — Information about time/condition
2. **On the telephone** — Information about place/medium
3. **With great, abiding pleasure** — Information about manner
4. **In the chapters that follow** — Information about place/time
5. **At a certain time** — Information about time
6. **With equal respect and love** — Information about manner
**Common Prepositions:**
**More Examples:**
**Exam Important:** Prepositional phrases add detail and clarity to sentences. Identifying them helps in sentence analysis and grammar comprehension.
---
**Technique:** When rearranging jumbled words, look for:
1. Subject (who is doing the action)
2. Verb (the action)
3. Object (who/what receives the action)
4. Prepositional phrases (providing additional information)
**Example Arrangements:**
1. **Jumbled:** barked/at the strangers/the dog/loudly/the house/walking by
**Arranged:** The dog barked loudly at the strangers walking by the house.
2. **Jumbled:** wrote/my classmate/during the/a story/summer vacations
**Arranged:** My classmate wrote a story during the summer vacations.
3. **Jumbled:** enjoyed/under the trees/they/by the lake/a picnic
**Arranged:** They enjoyed a picnic under the trees by the lake.
4. **Jumbled:** in his/grandfather's room/hung/he/the painting
**Arranged:** He hung the painting in his grandfather's room.
5. **Jumbled:** studied/with great determination/for/students/the/exam
**Arranged:** The students studied for the exam with great determination.
**Strategy:** Start with the subject, then place the verb, then object, then prepositional phrases in logical order.
---
**Key Character Traits:**
**1. Visionary and Idealistic**
**2. Selfless and Dedicated**
**3. Humble and Principled**
**4. Reflective and Wise**
**5. Family-Oriented**
**6. Realistic and Practical**
**Textual Evidence:**
"...I knew I could make a more meaningful contribution by working here in Anand, Gujarat."
"If you are always honest to yourself, it does not take much effort in always being honest with others."
---
**Major Themes:**
**1. Meaningful Work Over Material Success**
**2. The Power of Written Communication**
**3. Values and Integrity as Life's Foundation**
**4. Life as a Privilege and Responsibility**
**5. Sacrifice and Commitment**
**6. True Happiness vs. External Recognition**
**7. Generational Legacy**
---
**For Class 8 NCF 2023 (Values and Dispositions):**
This chapter develops the following values in students:
---
**Question Types Likely to Appear:**
**1. Comprehension-Based Questions:**
**2. Character Analysis:**
**3. Theme-Based Questions:**
**4. Vocabulary Questions:**
**5. Grammar-Based Questions:**
**6. Fact vs. Opinion:**
**7. Literary Devices:**
**8. Application Questions:**
**Sample Board Exam Questions to Practice:**
1. What does Dr. Kurien mean by "failure is not about not succeeding. Rather, it is about not putting in your best effort"?
2. How did Dr. Kurien's choice to work in Anand reflect his values and commitment to society?
3. Identify two facts and two opinions from the letter. Justify your answers.
4. Explain the paradox: "There is little correlation between the circumstances of people's lives and how happy they are."
5. Write a paragraph explaining why the author considers written communication superior to telephone conversations.
6. How does the anecdote about the Padma Vibhushan medal convey an important life lesson?
---
**Context:** This chapter is a personal letter from an elder to a younger family member. Students should understand formal and informal letter structures.
**Parts of a Formal Letter:**
1. **Sender's Address** (optional in personal letters)
2. **Date**
3. **Receiver's Address** (optional in personal letters)
4. **Salutation/Greeting**
5. **Body of the Letter** (organized in paragraphs)
6. **Closing/Sign-off**
7. **Signature**
**Key Features of Dr. Kurien's Letter:**
**Writing Tips for Students:**
---
**Context:** Students will listen to a passage about Evelyn Glennie, a famous musician who overcome hearing loss.
**Relevant Vocabulary from Listening Exercise:**
| Word | Meaning |
|------|---------|
| Percussionist | A person who plays drums and similar instruments |
| Impaired | Weakened or damaged in function |
| Vibration | Movement back and forth; trembling sensation |
| Perseverance | The ability to keep going despite difficulties |
| Advocate | A person who supports or promotes a cause |
**Connection to Main Text:**
Both Dr. Kurien and Evelyn Glennie demonstrate:
---
**For Exam Preparation:**
1. **On Communication:**
"Writing is different. Writing—even if it is a letter—not only conveys our present concerns and views of the events taking place around us but it becomes a possession that can be treasured and re-read over the years, with great, abiding pleasure."
2. **On Life Choices:**
"I knew I could make a more meaningful contribution by working here in Anand, Gujarat."
3. **On Integrity:**
"If you are always honest to yourself, it does not take much effort in always being honest with others."
4. **On Life's Purpose:**
"Life is a privilege and to waste it would be wrong."
5. **On Failure:**
"Failure is not about not succeeding. Rather, it is about not putting in your best effort and not contributing, however modestly, to the common good."
6. **On True Rewards:**
"Remember, rewards that come to you then are the only true rewards for a life well-spent."
7. **On Happiness:**
"There is little correlation between the circumstances of people's lives and how happy they are."
---
**Essential Takeaways for Students:**
1. **Written communication** creates lasting bonds and preserves wisdom for future generations
2. **Meaningful work** brings more satisfaction than wealth or status
3. **Integrity and honest** principles are the foundation of success
4. **Family support** is essential in pursuing meaningful goals
5. **Life is a privilege** that requires contributing to the common good
6. **True happiness** comes from effort and purpose, not from external circumstances or comparisons
7. **Each generation** must earn its own recognition and build on inherited values
8. **Sacrifice and commitment** are necessary parts of meaningful achievement
---
**What to Remember:**
**Time Management for Exam:**
**Quality of Answers:**
This chapter is designed to inspire students to think about their own values, choices, and contributions to society while developing their reading comprehension, vocabulary, and grammar skills.
Q1. Why does Verghese Kurien prefer writing letters over telephone calls?
Answer: C — Kurien explicitly states that writing conveys present concerns and views and becomes a possession treasured and re-read with great abiding pleasure, unlike the immediate but fleeting joy of telephone calls.
Q2. What does Kurien mean when he says 'choosing to lead one kind of life means putting aside the desire to pursue other options'?
Answer: B — This statement reflects that selecting one life path necessarily means not pursuing other careers, as Kurien exemplifies by choosing farming over metallurgy, the army, or becoming an NRI.
Q3. Which of the following is NOT a reason given by Kurien for his decision to work with dairy farmers?
Answer: C — Kurien explicitly states he could have pursued wealth through metallurgy or as an NRI, but chose farming instead; building wealth was never his motivation for serving farmers.
Q4. What transformation took place in Kurien fifty years before 2005, and what triggered it?
Answer: B — Kurien clearly states his transformation occurred fifty years ago when he agreed to work for a small cooperative of dairy farmers through a series of events that presented him with a life-changing choice.
Q5. Ramesh reads his grandfather's old letters and discovers memories of events from fifty years ago. What concept from Kurien's letter best explains why these letters are valuable to Ramesh?
Answer: B — Kurien's central point is that letters, unlike telephone calls, become possessions treasured and re-read over years with abiding pleasure, which directly applies to Ramesh's experience discovering his grandfather's memories.
Q6. According to Kurien, what is the relationship between personal integrity and integrity with others?
Answer: B — Kurien directly states that personal integrity—being honest to yourself—is the foundation, and if you maintain it, being honest with others follows naturally without much effort.
Q7. What did Kurien and his grandmother tell Siddharth about the Padma Vibhushan medal when he asked to keep it?
Answer: B — Kurien tells Siddharth the medal was his as much as his grandfather's, but the real challenge was to earn his own reward for work in his lifetime, not merely keep someone else's award.
Q8. Which statement best captures Kurien's philosophy about failure?
Answer: B — Kurien explicitly defines failure as not putting in best effort and not contributing modestly to common good, regardless of whether external success is achieved.
Q9. What does Kurien reveal about the relationship between life circumstances and happiness in people?
Answer: B — Kurien observes that there is little correlation between people's circumstances and their happiness; the problem is comparing ourselves with others' images of perfection rather than cherishing what we have.
Q10. Why does Kurien emphasize that his achievements should be seen as recognition of 'many people's' work rather than his own alone?
Answer: B — Kurien stresses that his contributions were possible through values inherited from family and mentors, and he worked with many privileged people, showing that meaningful achievement requires collective effort and values passed through generations.
What is the main difference between telephone calls and written letters according to Kurien?
Telephone calls give fleeting joy while letters convey lasting abiding pleasure that can be treasured and re-read for years.
Why did Verghese Kurien choose to work with dairy farmers instead of pursuing other careers?
He realized through a series of events that he could make a more meaningful contribution by working in Anand, Gujarat, serving farmers' needs.
What does Kurien mean by 'integrity is being honest to yourself'?
If you are always honest to yourself about your values and actions, it becomes easy to be honest with others.
What was the grandchild's innocent request at the Padma Vibhushan ceremony in Delhi?
Siddharth asked if he could keep the Padma Vibhushan medal that was awarded to his grandfather.
Define 'abiding pleasure' as used in Kurien's letter.
Abiding pleasure is a feeling of happiness that continues for a long time, not something momentary or fleeting.
What values did Kurien say he inherited and consistently adhered to throughout his life?
He inherited values from his parents and family elders, particularly integrity, which he learned was being honest to oneself first.
According to Kurien, what is the true meaning of failure in life?
Failure is not about not succeeding but about not putting in your best effort and not contributing to the common good.
Why does Kurien emphasize that recognitions should not satisfy a person completely?
Because recognitions only acknowledge past achievements; the real challenge is to earn your own reward through work in your lifetime.
What role did Kurien's grandmother play in his life's journey?
She ardently supported his choice to live and work in Anand despite its lack of comforts, giving him everlasting strength.
What is the correlation Kurien draws between circumstances and happiness?
There is little correlation between people's life circumstances and their happiness; comparing with others' images of perfection makes us unhappy.
What does Verghese Kurien mean when he says that writing a letter gives 'abiding pleasure' while telephone calls give only 'fleeting joy'? [2 marks]
Explain how letters can be treasured and re-read over years, creating lasting happiness. Contrast this with the momentary nature of spoken conversation that disappears once the call ends.
Kurien chose to work with dairy farmers instead of pursuing metallurgy, an army commission, or becoming a successful NRI. Analyze what this decision reveals about his values and priorities in life. [3 marks]
Discuss how his choice reflects the value of meaningful contribution to common good over personal prestige and wealth. Mention the role of his grandmother's support and his realization about making a difference in Anand.
Kurien tells his grandson that 'failure is not about not succeeding. Rather, it is about not putting in your best effort and not contributing, however modestly, to the common good.' Explain this definition of failure and discuss how it challenges the common understanding of failure in society. How does this philosophy help a person live a more fulfilling life? [5 marks]
Distinguish between failure as external non-achievement versus failure as internal lack of effort and contribution. Show how this redefines success to focus on personal integrity, effort, and service rather than results. Discuss how this philosophy prevents regret and builds meaningful life satisfaction.
Practice with interactive flashcards, mind maps, upload your own chapters and get AI study kits instantly
Try StudyOS Free →