Play Introduction and Genre
**"On the Face of It"** is a one-act play written by **Susan Hill**, a contemporary British dramatist. This is a realistic drama featuring **only two characters**: Mr Lamb, an elderly man, and Derry, a fourteen-year-old boy. The play explores **disability, isolation, self-perception, and human connection**. It was first performed in 1975 and remains a significant work in CBSE Class 12 Vistas curriculum because it addresses **universal themes of acceptance, prejudice, and the power of positive human relationships**.
**Genre Characteristics:**
Realistic/contemporary drama
Two-character play (minimalist structure)
Stream-of-consciousness dialogue revealing inner thoughts
Uses **symbolism** (the garden, the gate, tin leg, burned face)
Explores psychological barriers alongside physical ones
Ending is tragic yet suggests possibility of redemption
Plot Summary and Structure
The play unfolds in **three scenes**: Scene One is set in Mr Lamb's garden (primary action), Scene Two shifts to Derry's house (conflict with mother), and Scene Three returns to the garden (climactic moment).
**Scene One Overview:**
Derry trespasses into Mr Lamb's garden, believing it empty
Mr Lamb discovers him and strikes up a conversation
Derry is withdrawn and defiant, afraid of people's reactions to his **acid-burned face**
Mr Lamb reveals his own **disability: a tin leg from wartime injury**
Through gentle questioning and philosophical remarks, Mr Lamb helps Derry see beyond physical appearance
Mr Lamb proposes Derry help him pick crab apples
Scene ends with Derry leaving but promising to return
Mr Lamb's aside reveals he doubts Derry will come back (setting up dramatic irony)
**Scene Two Overview:**
Takes place at Derry's house
Mother warns Derry against visiting Mr Lamb; she has heard negative rumors about him
Derry argues passionately that Mr Lamb has given him something no one else has: validation and purpose
The scene reveals **Derry's desperation to escape his suffocating home environment**
Derry declares he will return to Mr Lamb's garden regardless
He runs off, repeating "I want the world....I want it....I want it"
**Scene Three Overview:**
Set in Mr Lamb's garden
Derry returns to find Mr Lamb has fallen from a ladder while trying to pick crab apples
Mr Lamb lies injured and possibly dead on the grass
Derry's **emotional breakdown and weeping** show how deeply he has bonded with Mr Lamb in just one meeting
The tragic ending undercuts the hope established in Scene One
Final line: Derry says "I came back. Lamey-Lamb. I did.....come back" — emphasizing how his return proves Mr Lamb's doubts wrong, but too late
Main Characters: Analysis and Development
Derry (Derek)
**Physical Characteristics:**
14 years old (says "I'm fourteen")
**Face severely burned with acid** (not from fire, as Mr Lamb initially guesses)
"It ate my face up. It ate me up. And now it's like this and it won't ever be any different"
Has both arms, legs, eyes, ears intact — physically capable
Socially **withdrawn and defiant**, self-isolated despite living with family
**Psychological Profile:**
**Extreme low self-esteem** rooted in physical appearance
Believes everyone fears him: "People are afraid of me"
Preemptively hostile to shield himself from rejection
Cynical about human kindness: dismisses "Beauty and the Beast" as false consolation
Obsessive about his appearance: "When I look in the mirror, and see it, I'm afraid of me"
**Alienation**: "I don't like being with people. Any people"
Lives in anticipatory anxiety, imagining worst responses
**Development Through Play:**
Initially defensive and aggressive with Mr Lamb
Gradually opens up as Mr Lamb refuses to pity or avoid discussing his face
Shows capacity for humor (laughs at the story of the man who locked himself in the room)
Begins to question his assumptions about society
Shows genuine interest in Mr Lamb's philosophy and life
**Critical moment**: Derry asserts his agency — "They tell me. Do you have to agree?"
By end of Scene One, Derry has **shifted from resignation to hope and determination**
His return in Scene Three proves he has made a choice to engage with the world
**Key Quotes Revealing Character:**
"Underneath, you are afraid. Anybody would be. I am. When I look in the mirror, and see it, I'm afraid of me."
"It won't make my face change."
"I don't know what I want. I want....something no one else has got or ever will have. Something just mine."
"Oh no, oh no. Because if I don't go back there, I'll never go anywhere in this world again."
Mr Lamb
**Physical Characteristics:**
Elderly man, exact age unspecified
**Tin leg** (prosthetic limb replacing leg blown off in war)
Lives alone in a large house with no curtains
Sits in garden frequently, observing nature
Still capable of climbing ladders and managing physical tasks independently
**Philosophical Approach:**
Sees **interconnectedness of all things**: "There's fruit and there are flowers, and trees and herbs....I grow weeds there. Why is one green, growing plant called a weed and another 'flower'? Where's the difference. It's all life....growing. Same as you and me."
Refuses to reduce people to single defining characteristics
Believes in **universal human potential**: "you've got two arms, two legs and eyes and ears, you've got a tongue and a brain. You'll get on the way you want"
Maintains open-door policy: "The gate's always open. All welcome"
Values observation and listening over judgment: "Watching. Listening. Thinking"
**Unconventional Methods of Connection:**
Does not pity or avoid difficult topics (refuses to change subject when Derry brings up his face)
Asks probing questions rather than making statements
Uses storytelling to convey wisdom (the man who locked himself in the room)
Employs **reframing**: changes how Derry perceives his own limitations
Shows non-judgment: "You think what you please" when Derry disbelieves his claim about visitors
Demonstrates self-acceptance: not bothered by kids calling him "Lamey-Lamb"
**Loneliness and Disappointment:**
Mr Lamb reveals signs of isolation: he mentions having "hundreds" of friends, but lives alone
Children visit for apples and toffee; people come to sit by the fire
**Critical subtext**: Mr Lamb may be more isolated than he admits; his constant philosophical talk suggests he has little genuine human connection
His final aside — "They never do come back" — reveals **deep disappointment and lower expectations**
Yet he does not let this prevent him from inviting Derry, showing **resilience and hope despite repeated disappointment**
**Ways Mr Lamb Overcomes Loneliness:**
Maintains curiosity: "I'm interested in anybody. Anything"
Keeps the garden open and welcoming
Engages deeply with whoever arrives, without precondition
Finds joy in small things: bees "singing," crab apples, weeds, spider silk
Defines friendship loosely — not dependent on repeated meetings or formality
Continues to offer companionship and tasks (picking apples) to establish purpose
**Key Quotes Revealing Character:**
"I'm old. You're young. You've got a burned face, I've got a tin leg. Not important."
"Everything's yours if you want it. What's mine is anybody's."
"There's nothing God made that doesn't interest me."
"They never do come back. Not them. Never do come back."
Major Themes
Disability and Self-Perception vs. Social Perception
**Definition:** The play distinguishes between **internal self-image** (how the disabled person sees themselves) and **external perception** (how society views disability).
**Textual Evidence:**
Derry's acid-burned face is permanent, but his limitation is primarily **psychological and social**, not functional
He can walk, talk, think, and work; his exclusion comes from anticipated rejection, not actual incapacity
Mr Lamb's tin leg genuinely restricts mobility, yet he functions independently and welcomes life
**Key dialogue**: Mr Lamb says, "Acid only burns your face" but hatred "can burn yourself away inside" — suggesting **internal suffering is more damaging than external disfigurement**
**Examination Significance:**
Shows that disability's impact depends partly on **social attitudes and self-acceptance**
Challenges audience to examine their own prejudices
Demonstrates that a single physical characteristic need not define a person's potential or worth
Prejudice and Alienation
**Definition:** Both characters experience social alienation — Derry due to his appearance, Mr Lamb due to age and disability — yet they respond differently.
**How Prejudice Manifests:**
Woman at bus stop: "That's a face only a mother could love"
Derry's mother warns him against visiting Mr Lamb (rumor and suspicion without evidence)
Children mock Mr Lamb with "Lamey-Lamb" (though Hill suggests the teasing is not malicious)
Derry preemptively isolates himself, assuming people will reject him
**Derry's Alienation Process:**
**Self-imposed isolation**: "I don't like being with people"
**Internalized prejudice**: "I'm afraid of me"
**Catastrophizing**: believes one cruel comment defines all of society's judgment
**Learned helplessness**: "Who'd let me? Not one" (regarding romantic possibility)
**Mr Lamb's Response to Prejudice:**
Does not internalize mockery: "It doesn't trouble me"
Separates the person from the prejudice: "It's a game. They're not afraid of me"
Continues to engage: keeps gate open despite knowing kids mock him
Models **acceptance of self** as antidote to social prejudice
**Examination Focus:**
The play suggests prejudice is often **rooted in fear and unfamiliarity**, not truth
A single rejection or cruel remark can disproportionately shape self-perception
**Active engagement with others**, despite risk, is necessary to overcome alienation
The Garden as Inclusive Space and Metaphor
**Symbolic Function of the Garden:**
**Physical inclusivity**: open gate, always accessible, welcomes "anybody"
**Natural world as equalizer**: plants, insects, and weather do not judge
Mr Lamb grows both "flowers" and "weeds" — rejecting false hierarchies
**Freedom from surveillance**: no curtains mean no hiding; light and darkness both admitted
**Place of transformation**: where Derry shifts from despair to hope, isolation to connection
**Garden Details and Meaning:**
**Crab apples (windfalls)**: golden, ripe, beautiful in imperfection — like Derry
**Weeds**: Mr Lamb's deliberate cultivation of what others discard; metaphor for accepting all life
**Bees**: Mr Lamb hears them "singing" (interprets them generously), suggesting how we choose to perceive the world
**No curtains**: transparency, openness, refusal to hide or exclude
**Key Exchange:**
Derry: "I'd like a place like this. A garden. I'd like a house with no curtains."
Mr Lamb: "The gate's always open."
**Implication**: belonging is available if one chooses to engage
The Power of Acceptance and Non-Judgment
**How Mr Lamb Accepts Derry:**
Does not shy away from discussing the acid burn
Does not offer false comfort ("You'll change," "It's not important")
Does not reduce Derry to his appearance: "You're a boy who came into the garden. Plenty do."
Treats him as **fully human**: "I'm interested in anybody. Anything"
**Derry's Response to Acceptance:**
Initial defensive hostility softens
Begins to ask genuine questions about Mr Lamb
Expresses affection: "I like it here"
Makes autonomous decision to return (defying mother)
**Critical realization**: "If I don't go back there, I'll never go anywhere in this world again" — acceptance by one person unlocks possibility
**Distinction from Pity:**
Mr Lamb deliberately **avoids pity** (which humiliates and reduces)
He avoids false equivalence ("You'll be fine," "It's not that bad")
Instead, he **normalizes**: treats Derry as one human among many, each different
This **non-sentimental approach** is what gives Derry hope
Dramatic Devices and Structure
Dialogue as Character Revelation
The play relies almost entirely on **dialogue** to convey character, theme, and plot. There are no stage directions describing internal emotional states; **all psychology emerges through speech patterns**.
**Derry's Speech Patterns:**
Begins with short, defensive statements: "I'd not come to steal anything"
Becomes increasingly eloquent and philosophical as he opens up
Uses repetition to emphasize emotional intensity: "I want it....I want it....I want it"
Asks questions in rapid succession when anxious (rapid-fire interrogation style)
Final scenes shift to poetic, emotional speech
**Mr Lamb's Speech Patterns:**
Slow, measured, **often replies with questions rather than declarations**
Uses storytelling and anecdote (the man in the locked room)
Philosophical and abstract (discussing weeds, the relative nature of beauty)
Rarely raises voice; maintains calm demeanor
His dialogue reveals **gentle wisdom through understatement**
Dramatic Irony
**Definition:** Audience knows something characters do not, creating tension.
**Key Instance:**
Mr Lamb says to himself: "They never do come back. Not them. Never do come back"
Audience then sees Scene Two (Derry's conflict with mother) and Scene Three (Derry's return)
**Irony**: Derry DOES return, but too late; Mr Lamb has fallen and is possibly dying
The very act of proving Mr Lamb wrong is forestalled by tragedy
**Effect on Audience:**
Creates **poignancy and pathos** — Derry's determination and growth are validated but cannot save Mr Lamb
Suggests that even when we overcome internal barriers and choose engagement, **external fate may intervene**
The Ending as Tragic but Transformative
**Why the Ending is Tragic:**
Mr Lamb's fall suggests **serious injury or death**
Derry's emotional breakdown shows how much he has invested in this relationship
The possibility that Derry has lost the one person who truly saw him is devastating
**Why the Ending Suggests Transformation:**
Derry **did return** — he overcame his fear and his mother's prohibition
His declaration "I came back. Lamey-Lamb. I did.....come back" shows **agency and choice**
His tears demonstrate **emotional depth and capacity for connection**, not continued isolation
The audience knows Derry has fundamentally changed, even if Mr Lamb may not survive to see the full result
**Interpretation:**
The play suggests **growth and choosing engagement is valuable even if outcomes are uncertain**
Derry's transformation is real; it does not depend on Mr Lamb surviving
The ending leaves **moral ambiguity** — Is it tragic? Is it redemptive? Both. This is the play's power.
Literary Devices in the Text
Symbolism
**The Tin Leg:**
Represents **visible disability** that Mr Lamb has integrated into life
Cannot be hidden (unlike internal trauma or prejudice), yet Mr Lamb thrives
Suggests that **acceptance of unchangeable reality** is the path forward
**The Burned Face:**
Represents **permanent disfigurement** that Derry believes defines his worth
Contrasts with Mr Lamb's leg: both are permanent, but psychological response differs
Symbolizes how **society marks and categorizes the "different"**
**The Open Gate:**
Represents **unconditional access, welcome, and belonging**
Contrasts with Derry's self-imposed isolation and his mother's protective barriers
Becomes the key metaphor for how inclusion is offered (by Mr Lamb) but must be chosen (by Derry)
**The Garden:**
**Eden-like space** of beauty, growth, and acceptance
Opposite of Derry's home (enclosed, anxious, pitying)
Nature itself (bees, flowers, weeds, seasons) serves as model for non-judgmental existence
**The Ladder:**
Suggests **reaching, growth, aspiration**
Mr Lamb's fall from the ladder undercuts optimism with tragedy
Represents how even those who have overcome limitations remain vulnerable
Imagery
**Visual Imagery of Light and Dark:**
Mr Lamb's house has "no curtains" — he admits both light and darkness
Derry moves from darkness (isolation, despair) toward light (connection, possibility)
Garden setting emphasizes **natural light, shadow, growth**
**Imagery of Burning and Acid:**
"It ate my face up. It ate me up"
Creates visceral understanding of trauma, permanent damage
Contrasts with Mr Lamb's stoicism: "Tin doesn't hurt, boy"
**Sensory Imagery:**
**Sound**: birdsong, rustling leaves, bees humming/singing
Mr Lamb's interpretation of bee sounds as "singing" rather than "buzzing" shows **how we choose to perceive**
Derry's heightened sensitivity to what people say and how they look shows **hypervigilance** born of shame
Metaphor
**"Beauty and the Beast" Metaphor:**
Derry dismisses the fairy tale: the beast "wouldn't" change; "I won't change"
Yet Mr Lamb embodies a counter-metaphor: his "beastly" leg and age do not prevent his kindness or others' affection
The play suggests the metaphor itself is **limiting and false**
**"The World as a Garden":**
Mr Lamb says the garden is "the world, as much as anywhere"
Suggests that **belonging and acceptance are available if we choose to see the world as accessible**
Contrasts Derry's view of the world as inherently hostile
**"Burning":**
Acid burn as literal trauma becomes metaphor for **emotional damage from prejudice**
Mr Lamb's warning: hatred can "burn yourself away inside"
Theme Analysis: Disability, Acceptance, and Choice
The Distinction Between Disability and Handicap
**Disability** (physical/medical fact): Derry's burned face, Mr Lamb's missing leg
**Handicap** (social/psychological consequence): Derry's isolation, fear, exclusion
**Key Insight from the Play:**
Derry's handicap is **not caused by his disability alone** but by **internalized shame and social rejection**
Mr Lamb demonstrates that a disability need not create a handicap if **one maintains self-acceptance and agency**
The play's critique: society creates handicaps by rejecting the disabled; the disabled often internalize this rejection
The Role of Individual Choice
**Derry's Choices:**
1. **First choice**: To trespass into the garden (active risk-taking)
2. **Second choice**: To confess his burned face and listen to Mr Lamb's philosophy (emotional openness)
3. **Third choice**: To defy his mother and return to Mr Lamb (assertion of autonomy)
**Mr Lamb's Choices:**
To keep the gate open despite being mocked
To engage with each visitor as a full person, not a project or charity case
To live a life of openness (no curtains) despite vulnerability
To continue hoping despite repeated disappointment
**Examination Point:**
The play emphasizes **choice as fundamental to human dignity**
Mr Lamb repeatedly asks Derry "Do you have to agree?" — highlighting that **compliance is not the only option**
Derry's growth is measured by his increasing **assertion of choice** over family and social pressure
The Question Posed by the Ending
The play does not provide easy answers about whether **choosing engagement and vulnerability is worth the risk**. Mr Lamb falls; Derry arrives too late. Yet Derry has already **transformed** by choosing to return.
**For Board Exams:**
Students should recognize that the play **validates Derry's choice** even though the outcome is tragic
The ending suggests that **becoming fully human requires risk and that failure to engage guarantees failure**
The play is ultimately **optimistic about human potential** even while acknowledging life's harshness
Answers to "Reading with Insight" Questions
Question 1: What Draws Derry to Mr Lamb Despite Himself?
**Answer Structure:**
**Non-judgment**: Mr Lamb refuses to pity or avoid discussion of Derry's face
**Acceptance as a full person**: Mr Lamb treats him as "a boy who came into the garden," not as a case study
**Philosophical depth**: Mr Lamb offers ideas Derry has never heard (about weeds, about self-perception, about the world being accessible)
**Modeling of acceptance**: Mr Lamb's own comfort with his tin leg and with being mocked shows Derry an alternative way to live
**Offering of agency**: Mr Lamb asks questions rather than dictating; he respects Derry's choices
**The garden itself**: A physical space that feels safe, beautiful, and inclusive
**Genuine interest**: Mr Lamb's curiosity about Derry feels authentic, not performative
**Most Important:** What draws Derry is the **experience of being seen and accepted as a whole person**, which stands in stark contrast to his experience at home and in society.
Question 2: Loneliness and Mr Lamb's Coping Mechanisms
**Section Displaying Loneliness:**
Final aside of Scene One: "They never do come back. Not them. Never do come back"
This is a **rare moment of honesty** revealing his isolation and repeated disappointment
**Ways He Overcomes Loneliness:**
**Maintains curiosity and openness**: "I'm interested in anybody. Anything"
**Keeps the gate always open**: practical symbol of refusing to isolate
**Engages deeply with whoever arrives**: does not minimize or rush conversations
**Finds joy in small things**: nature, bees, gardening; does not depend on human company alone
**Redefines friendship broadly**: does not require formality, repeated meetings, or extensive knowledge
**Continues to hope**: despite knowing people "never do come back," he invites the next person
**Offers purpose and tasks**: picks apples with Derry, makes toffee, creates reasons for people to visit
**Key Examination Point:**
Mr Lamb's loneliness is real, but he does **not let it prevent him from being kind or welcoming**
His coping is **active and generative**, not passive resignation
Question 3: Physical Impairment vs. Alienation
**Statement to Analyze:**
"The actual pain or inconvenience caused by a physical impairment is often much less than the sense of alienation felt by the person with disabilities."
**Evidence from the Play:**
**Derry's Case:**
His acid burn causes no physical pain (it is healed)
His suffering is **entirely psychological and social**: shame, fear of rejection, belief that he is unlovable
His limitation is **self-imposed**: he withdraws before others reject him
The impairment itself is manageable; the alienation is devastating
**Mr Lamb's Case:**
His missing leg causes **occasional pain** ("in wet weather")
He says explicitly: "It doesn't signify"
He manages the practical inconvenience independently (climbing ladders, walking)
He does **not suffer alienation** because he does not accept society's judgment of him
**Conclusion:**
The play **validates the statement completely**
Physical impairment is manageable; **alienation (social rejection + internalized shame) is the real disability**
The key difference between Derry and Mr Lamb is **not their physical conditions** but their **psychological response** to social judgment
The implication: **society creates handicap through alienation; individuals can resist alienation through self-acceptance and engagement**
**For Board Exams:**
This question tests understanding of the play's central theme: that **disability's impact is partly psychological and partly social**
Strong answers will distinguish between the physical fact and the emotional/social consequence
Students should reference specific textual evidence (the woman's cruel comment, Derry's self-isolation, Mr Lamb's refusal to be troubled)
Important Quotes for Memorization and Exam Use
**On Prejudice and Fear:**
"Underneath, you are afraid. Anybody would be. I am. When I look in the mirror, and see it, I'm afraid of me."
"There's nothing God made that doesn't interest me."
**On Acceptance and Disability:**
"I'm old. You're young. You've got a burned face, I've got a tin leg. Not important."
"It's all relative. Beauty and the beast."
**On Isolation and Engagement:**
"Everything's yours if you want it. What's mine is anybody's."
"You could lock yourself up in a room and never leave it."
**On Choice and Agency:**
"Do you have to agree?" (Mr Lamb to Derry)
"If I don't go back there, I'll never go anywhere in this world again."
**On the Garden:**
"The gate's always open."
"People are never just nothing. Never."
**On Internal vs. External Harm:**
"Acid only burns your face. [But hatred can] burn yourself away inside."
---
Summary for Board Exam Preparation
**Key Points to Remember:**
1. **Two-character structure** allows for deep psychological exploration without distraction
2. **Derry's transformation** from isolation to engagement is real and permanent, despite tragic ending
3. **Mr Lamb's philosophy** — that accepting oneself allows others to accept you — is the play's central wisdom
4. **Symbolism** (garden, gate, tin leg, burned face) must be recognized and analyzed
5. **The ending is both tragic and validating** — Derry proves Mr Lamb wrong (he did return) but too late
6. **Themes of disability, prejudice, and choice** are interconnected and inseparable
7. **Dialogue reveals psychology** — pay attention to speech patterns and what is NOT said as much as what is
For any board exam question, anchor your answer in **specific textual evidence** and analyze how **character, dialogue, symbol, and theme work together** to create meaning.