StudyOSStudyOS CBSE Study Material, Class 5–12

Private, Public and Global Enterprises

NCERT Class 11 · Business Studies Based on NCERT Class 11 Business Studies textbook · Free CBSE study kit

Everything you need to ace this chapter, in one place.
Notes · Mind Map · Quiz · Assertion-Reason · Case Studies · Question Bank · Past Papers

Get Full Study Kit →
Studying with friends? Send them this chapter.

Chapter Notes

Overview
This chapter explains the coexistence of private, public, and global enterprises in India's mixed economy. It covers the features, merits, and limitations of three forms of public enterprises: departmental undertakings, statutory corporations, and government companies. The chapter also discusses the changing role of the public sector post-1991, the characteristics of global enterprises (MNCs), and the benefits of joint ventures and Public-Private Partnerships (PPP). The one big idea is that India's economic landscape is a blend of government-owned, privately-owned, and multinational corporations, each with distinct structures, objectives, and operational flexibilities.
Key Concepts (16)
Private Sector
The part of the economy consisting of businesses owned by individuals or a group of individuals, such as sole proprietorship, partnership, joint Hindu family, cooperative, and company.
e.g. A neighbourhood grocery store owned by a single person or a big retail chain like Reliance Fresh.
Public Sector
The part of the economy consisting of various organisations owned and managed by the government, either partly or wholly owned by the central or state government.
e.g. Indian Railways, Post and Telegraph Department, and Steel Authority of India Limited (SAIL).
Mixed Economy
An economic system where both privately owned and government-owned business enterprises are allowed to operate.
e.g. India, where private companies like Tata Motors and public sector units like BHEL coexist.
Departmental Undertaking
The oldest and most traditional form of organising public enterprises, established as departments of the ministry and considered an extension of the ministry itself, with no independent legal entity.
e.g. Indian Railways and the Post and Telegraph Department.
Statutory Corporation
A public enterprise brought into existence by a Special Act of the Parliament, which defines its powers, functions, and rules; it is a corporate body with financial independence and operating flexibility.
e.g. Life Insurance Corporation of India (LIC) and the Food Corporation of India (FCI).
Government Company
A company registered under the Companies Act, 2013, in which not less than 51% of the paid-up capital is held by the central government, state government(s), or both, and includes a subsidiary of such a company.
e.g. Hindustan Machine Tools (HMT) and Bharat Heavy Electricals Limited (BHEL).
Disinvestment
The sale of equity shares of public sector enterprises to the private sector and the public, with the objective of raising resources and encouraging wider participation in ownership.
e.g. The government selling its stake in companies like ONGC or Coal India to private investors.
Global Enterprises (Multinational Corporations - MNCs)
Huge industrial organisations that extend their industrial and marketing operations through a network of branches in several countries, characterised by huge size, advanced technology, and centralised control.
e.g. Coca-Cola, Microsoft, and Toyota operating in India through subsidiaries or collaborations.
Joint Venture
The pooling of resources and expertise by two or more businesses to achieve a particular goal, with risks and rewards shared; can be contractual or equity-based.
e.g. Maruti Suzuki India Limited, a joint venture between the Government of India and Suzuki Motor Corporation of Japan.
Public Private Partnership (PPP)
A relationship between public and private entities for the development of infrastructure and other services, where tasks, obligations, and risks are allocated optimally between the partners.
e.g. Kundli Manesar Expressway Ltd., where the government provided land and the private company laid the surface.
Memorandum of Understanding (MoU)
A system under which public sector units are granted greater autonomy but held accountable for specified results, signed between the PSU and its administrative ministry.
e.g. A PSU like SAIL signing an MoU with the Ministry of Steel to achieve specific production targets.
Board for Industrial and Financial Reconstruction (BIFR)
A board to which all sick public sector units are referred to decide whether a unit should be restructured or closed down.
e.g. A loss-making PSU being referred to BIFR for revival or winding up.
National Renewal Fund
A fund set up by the government to retrain or redeploy retrenched labour and provide compensation to public sector employees seeking voluntary retirement.
e.g. Workers of a closed PSU receiving compensation under the Voluntary Retirement Scheme from this fund.
Import Substitution
A strategy aimed at being self-reliant by establishing public sector companies in heavy engineering to replace imported machinery and goods.
e.g. Establishment of heavy engineering PSUs during the Second and Third Five Year Plans to reduce dependence on foreign machinery.
Contractual Joint Venture (CJV)
A type of joint venture where a new jointly-owned entity is not created; parties only agree to work together without sharing ownership, but exercise some control.
e.g. A franchisee relationship, such as a local restaurant operating under the brand name of a global chain.
Equity-based Joint Venture (EJV)
A joint venture where a separate business entity, jointly owned by two or more parties, is formed; involves shared ownership, management, and profits/losses.
e.g. A new company formed by two firms to manufacture electric vehicles, with both holding equity shares.
How It Works
Formation of a Departmental Undertaking
  1. The enterprise is established as a department of a ministry, without any separate legal entity.
  2. Funding comes directly from the Government Treasury through annual budget appropriations.
  3. Revenue earned is paid into the treasury, and the enterprise is subject to government accounting and audit controls.
  4. Employees are government servants, headed by IAS officers or civil servants transferable between ministries.
  5. The enterprise is directly controlled by the ministry and accountable to it.
💡 Students often forget that departmental undertakings have no independent legal status and are not autonomous; they are just extensions of the ministry.
Formation of a Statutory Corporation
  1. A Special Act is passed by the Parliament, defining the corporation's powers, functions, and rules.
  2. The corporation is created as a body corporate with a separate legal entity, able to sue and be sued.
  3. It is wholly owned by the state, but financed independently through borrowings and revenues.
  4. Employees are not government servants; their conditions of service are governed by the Act itself.
  5. The corporation enjoys operational flexibility but is subject to the provisions of the Act.
💡 Students often confuse statutory corporations with government companies; the key difference is that statutory corporations are created by a Special Act, not under the Companies Act.
Formation of a Government Company
  1. The company is registered under the Companies Act, 2013, as a private or public limited company.
  2. At least 51% of the paid-up capital is held by the central government, state government(s), or both.
  3. The company has a separate legal entity and can enter into contracts and acquire property in its own name.
  4. Management is regulated by the Companies Act, and employees are appointed per the company's own rules.
  5. An auditor is appointed by the Central Government, and the Annual Report is presented in Parliament or State Legislature.
💡 Students often miss that a government company can also be a private limited company, and that it is exempted from government accounting and audit rules.
Disinvestment of Public Sector Enterprises
  1. The government decides to sell equity shares of a select set of PSUs to the private sector and the public.
  2. The objective is to raise resources, reduce public debt, and encourage wider participation in ownership.
  3. The government reduces its equity in non-strategic PSUs to 26% or lower.
  4. The commercial risk is transferred to the private sector, and corporate governance is introduced.
  5. The process frees enterprises from government control, leading to more choices and better quality for consumers.
💡 Students often think disinvestment means the government completely sells off all shares; in reality, the government may retain up to 26% equity in non-strategic units.
Operation of a Global Enterprise (MNC)
  1. The MNC has its headquarters in its home country, exercising centralised control over all branches and subsidiaries.
  2. It raises huge capital from various sources globally, including equity shares, debentures, and international banks.
  3. It enters into foreign collaborations with local companies for technology transfer, production, and branding.
  4. It uses advanced technology and aggressive marketing strategies to expand its market territory across countries.
  5. It operates through a network of subsidiaries, branches, and affiliates in host countries, with no interference in day-to-day operations.
💡 Students often think MNCs have decentralised control; in fact, control is centralised at the headquarters, but day-to-day operations are not interfered with.
Formation of a Joint Venture
  1. Two or more businesses agree to pool resources and expertise for a common purpose and mutual benefit.
  2. The parties sign a memorandum of understanding (MoU) highlighting the basis of the joint venture agreement.
  3. The agreement specifies the sharing of capital, technology, human resources, risks, and rewards.
  4. A new entity may be created (equity-based JV) or the parties may work together without a new entity (contractual JV).
  5. All necessary governmental approvals and licences are obtained within a specified period.
💡 Students often forget that joint ventures can be contractual (no new entity) or equity-based (new entity created), and that the agreement must be thorough to avoid legal complications.
Exam Traps — Don't Make These Mistakes
⚠ Confusing 'Statutory Corporation' with 'Government Company'
✗ A statutory corporation is the same as a government company because both are owned by the government.
→ Statutory corporations are created by a Special Act of Parliament, while government companies are registered under the Companies Act, 2013. They have different legal foundations and operational rules.
✓ A statutory corporation is a public enterprise created by a Special Act of Parliament, whereas a government company is registered under the Companies Act, 2013, with at least 51% government shareholding.
⚠ Misunderstanding 'Disinvestment' as Complete Government Exit
✗ Disinvestment means the government sells all its shares and exits the company completely.
→ Disinvestment involves selling a portion of equity, not necessarily all. The government may retain up to 26% equity in non-strategic PSUs.
✓ Disinvestment is the sale of equity shares of public sector enterprises to the private sector and the public, with the government often retaining a minority stake (e.g., 26% or lower).
⚠ Thinking Departmental Undertakings are Autonomous
✗ Departmental undertakings enjoy autonomy and can take independent business decisions.
→ Departmental undertakings are not autonomous; they are part of a ministry, subject to direct government control, and employees cannot take independent decisions without ministry approval.
✓ Departmental undertakings are not autonomous; they are extensions of the ministry, subject to direct government control, and lack operational flexibility.
⚠ Confusing 'Global Enterprises' with 'Joint Ventures'
✗ A global enterprise is the same as a joint venture because both operate in multiple countries.
→ A global enterprise is a single MNC operating in multiple countries through branches/subsidiaries, while a joint venture is a collaboration between two or more businesses (which could be domestic or foreign) for a common purpose.
✓ A global enterprise is a large MNC with operations in several countries, whereas a joint venture is a partnership between two or more businesses (which may include an MNC) to pool resources for a specific goal.
⚠ Forgetting that Government Companies can be Private Limited
✗ A government company is always a public limited company because the government owns shares.
→ A government company can be formed as either a private limited company or a public limited company under the Companies Act, 2013.
✓ A government company may be formed as a private limited company or a public limited company, as per the Companies Act, 2013.
⚠ Misstating the Minimum Government Shareholding for a Government Company
✗ A government company is one where the government holds more than 50% of the shares.
→ The exact requirement is 'not less than 51% of the paid-up capital', not simply 'more than 50%'. The precise percentage matters in board exams.
✓ A government company is one in which not less than 51% of the paid-up capital is held by the central government, state government(s), or both.
Compare & Contrast
Legal status and creation
Departmental Undertaking
Statutory Corporation
A departmental undertaking is created as a department of a ministry with no separate legal entity, while a statutory corporation is created by a Special Act of Parliament and is a body corporate with a separate legal entity.
Mode of establishment
Statutory Corporation
Government Company
A statutory corporation is established by a Special Act of Parliament, whereas a government company is established by registration under the Companies Act, 2013.
Ownership
Private Sector
Public Sector
The private sector consists of businesses owned by individuals or groups of individuals, while the public sector consists of organisations owned and managed by the government (central or state).
Creation of a new entity
Contractual Joint Venture (CJV)
Equity-based Joint Venture (EJV)
In a CJV, no new jointly-owned entity is created; parties only agree to work together. In an EJV, a separate business entity jointly owned by the parties is formed.
Exam Focus
Marks pattern: Typically 2-3 MCQs (1 mark each), 1-2 short answer questions (3 marks each), and 1 long answer question (5-6 marks) on forms of public enterprises or changing role of public sector.
Most asked: Features, merits, and limitations of departmental undertakings, statutory corporations, and government companies · Changing role of the public sector post-1991 (disinvestment, MoU, reduction in reserved industries) · Features of global enterprises (MNCs) · Benefits of joint ventures · Difference between statutory corporation and government company
Don't skip: Compare and contrast departmental undertakings, statutory corporations, and government companies (5-6 marks); Explain the changing role of the public sector since 1991, including disinvestment and MoU (5-6 marks); Features of global enterprises (3-5 marks); Benefits of joint ventures (3-5 marks)
One-Line Revision (read aloud before the exam)
  1. The Indian economy is a mixed economy with both private and public sector enterprises.
  2. Departmental undertakings are the oldest form of public enterprises, directly under a ministry with no autonomy.
  3. Statutory corporations are created by a Special Act of Parliament and have operational flexibility.
  4. A government company must have at least 51% paid-up capital held by the government.
  5. Disinvestment involves selling equity shares of PSUs to the private sector and the public.
  6. Since 1991, only three industries are reserved for the public sector: atomic energy, arms, and rail transport.
  7. Global enterprises (MNCs) have huge capital, advanced technology, and centralised control from their home country.
  8. Joint ventures involve pooling resources and expertise for mutual benefit, with shared risks and rewards.
  9. A contractual joint venture does not create a new entity, while an equity-based joint venture does.
  10. Public Private Partnership (PPP) allocates tasks and risks between public and private partners for infrastructure projects.
  11. The MoU system grants autonomy to PSUs but holds them accountable for specified results.
  12. The National Renewal Fund provides compensation and retraining for retrenched PSU workers.
  13. Statutory corporations are not subject to government accounting rules, but departmental undertakings are.
  14. Government companies can be formed as private or public limited companies under the Companies Act, 2013.
  15. Joint ventures provide access to new markets, technology, innovation, and established brand names.

MCQs — 10 Questions with Answers

Q1. Which of the following is NOT a form of public sector enterprise?

  • A. Departmental undertaking
  • B. Statutory corporation
  • C. Private limited company ✓
  • D. Government company

Answer: C — A private limited company is a private sector enterprise; departmental undertakings, statutory corporations, and government companies are all public sector forms.

Q2. Post-Independence, India adopted which type of economic system?

  • A. Purely capitalist economy
  • B. Purely socialist economy
  • C. Mixed economy with public and private sectors ✓
  • D. Feudal economy

Answer: C — India's constitution and Industrial Policy Resolutions (1948, 1956) established a mixed economy where both government and private enterprises operate together.

Q3. A statutory corporation differs from a departmental undertaking primarily because it:

  • A. Is directly controlled by a ministry
  • B. Functions as an independent legal entity with its own rights and liabilities ✓
  • C. Has no accountability to Parliament
  • D. Cannot raise its own funds

Answer: B — A statutory corporation, created by Parliamentary Act, is an independent legal entity; a departmental undertaking remains an extension of the ministry without separate legal status.

Q4. What was the primary aim of the 1991 Industrial Policy regarding the public sector?

  • A. To increase government control over all industries
  • B. To eliminate the public sector completely
  • C. To promote disinvestment and allow greater private sector freedom ✓
  • D. To restrict foreign investment entirely

Answer: C — The 1991 policy marked a radical shift toward opening the economy, disinvesting in public units, and inviting foreign direct investment.

Q5. Anita reads that the government plans to disinvest its shares in a public company. This means:

  • A. The government is closing down the company completely
  • B. The government is reducing its shareholding by selling some shares ✓
  • C. The company is moving to a different country
  • D. The government is investing more money into the company

Answer: B — Disinvestment is the partial reduction of government shareholding through share sales; it does not mean complete closure (privatisation) or further investment.

Q6. Which statement correctly pairs a public enterprise form with its defining characteristic?

  • A. Departmental undertaking — independent legal entity with autonomy
  • B. Government company — organised under Companies Act with majority government shares ✓
  • C. Statutory corporation — directly managed as a ministry department
  • D. All forms have identical accountability mechanisms

Answer: B — Government companies are structured as companies under the Companies Act with the government holding majority shares; other pairings are incorrect.

Q7. Global enterprises (MNCs) gained entry into India after 1991 primarily because:

  • A. India became a socialist economy
  • B. The government liberalised the economy and invited foreign direct investment ✓
  • C. The government banned all domestic private sector companies
  • D. India joined the United Nations

Answer: B — The 1991 liberalisation policy explicitly invited FDI, opening India's economy to multinational corporations, marking a shift from the earlier protectionist approach.

Q8. Consider two scenarios: (1) The government sells 51% of NTPC shares to a private group, and (2) The government sells 40% of BHEL shares to foreign investors. Which statement is true? (A) Scenario 1 is disinvestment, Scenario 2 is privatisation. (B) Both scenarios are disinvestment. (C) Both scenarios are privatisation. (D) Neither involves government action.

  • A. Scenario 1 is disinvestment, Scenario 2 is privatisation
  • B. Both scenarios are disinvestment ✓
  • C. Both scenarios are privatisation
  • D. Neither involves government action

Answer: B — Both scenarios represent disinvestment because the government retains some ownership; privatisation occurs only when ownership is completely transferred to private hands (over 50% loss of control).

Q9. ASSERTION: Public enterprises are accountable to the public through Parliament. REASON: They use public funds and are owned by the public. Which is correct?

  • A. Both assertion and reason are true; reason explains assertion ✓
  • B. Both are true but reason does not explain assertion
  • C. Assertion is true but reason is false
  • D. Both assertion and reason are false

Answer: A — Public enterprises are indeed accountable to Parliament, and this accountability directly stems from public ownership and use of public funds, making the reason a valid explanation.

Q10. A joint venture between an Indian private company and a foreign MNC is typically established to leverage both partners' strengths. Which benefit is LEAST likely in such an arrangement?

  • A. Transfer of advanced technology and expertise
  • B. Access to foreign capital and markets
  • C. Guaranteed government monopoly in the domestic market ✓
  • D. Local employment and infrastructure development

Answer: C — Joint ventures do not guarantee monopoly status; competition in a liberalised economy is expected, whereas technology transfer, capital access, and employment are common, realistic benefits.

Flashcards

What is a departmental undertaking in the public sector?

A departmental undertaking is the oldest form of public enterprise established as a ministry department, not an independent legal entity, with employees as government employees.

Define a statutory corporation with one key feature.

A statutory corporation is a public enterprise created by a special Act of Parliament, functioning as an independent legal entity with its own rights and liabilities.

What is a government company in the public sector?

A government company is a public enterprise organised in the form of a private company under the Companies Act, with majority shares held by the government.

What does 'disinvestment' mean in the 1991 industrial policy context?

Disinvestment is the government's reduction of its shareholding in public sector units by selling shares, without completely privatising the company.

Name one key difference between private and public sector ownership.

Private sector is owned by individuals or groups and accountable to owners; public sector is owned by the public and accountable through Parliament.

What is a global enterprise or multinational corporation?

A global enterprise is a business organisation that operates in more than one country, often established after a country opens to foreign direct investment.

Why is India's economy called a 'mixed economy'?

India's economy is called mixed because both privately owned and government-owned business enterprises are allowed to operate side by side.

What are the three characteristics of a public enterprise?

Public enterprises are characterised by public ownership, use of public funds for activities, and public accountability through Parliament.

What was the major shift brought by the 1991 Industrial Policy?

The 1991 policy radically shifted toward disinvestment of public sector, greater private sector freedom, and inviting foreign direct investment into India.

State one advantage of a statutory corporation over a departmental undertaking.

A statutory corporation has greater autonomy and flexibility as an independent legal entity, compared to a departmental undertaking which is tied to ministry rules.

Important Board Questions

Define 'public enterprise' and state any two characteristics that distinguish it from a private enterprise. [2 marks]

Public enterprise definition: owned and managed by government, accountable via Parliament. Two characteristics: public ownership, public funds usage OR public accountability. Contrast with private: owned by individuals/groups, accountable to owners.

Explain the three forms of public sector enterprises (departmental undertakings, statutory corporations, and government companies) with one distinguishing feature of each. Why did the government choose multiple forms instead of just one? [5 marks]

Departmental: ministry extension, no independent legal status; Statutory: created by Act, independent entity; Government company: Companies Act form, company structure. Reason: different operational needs and autonomy requirements suit different industries; flexibility in governance and function.

Analyse how India's Industrial Policy evolved from 1948 to 1991 and explain why the 1991 policy is considered 'radically different.' How did this shift affect the entry of global enterprises? Provide relevant examples. [6 marks]

1948–1956: Clear public-private roles, public sector emphasis, mutual dependency. 1991: Disinvestment, private sector freedom, FDI invitation—radical reversal. Effect: MNCs (e.g., Coca-Cola, Maruti-Suzuki) entered post-1991 via joint ventures and FDI. Connect mixed economy logic: public + private + global coexistence now.

Assertion-Reason Questions for Private, Public and Global Enterprises

Q1. Assertion (A):

Departmental undertakings are not independent legal entities and must act through government officers and employees.

Reason (R):

This is because departmental undertakings are established as departments of a ministry and are considered extensions of the ministry itself.

Answer: A — Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A — Both the assertion and reason are true, and the reason correctly explains why departmental undertakings lack independent legal status. They are integral parts of the ministry structure, not autonomous organizations.

Q2. Assertion (A):

The 1991 Industrial Policy Resolution represented a radical departure from earlier policies regarding the role of public and private sectors.

Reason (R):

The 1991 policy promoted disinvestment of public sector enterprises and greater freedom to private sector, while inviting foreign direct investment.

Answer: A — Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A — Both statements are accurate. The 1991 policy was indeed radically different, shifting from the earlier emphasis on public sector importance to promoting privatization and liberalization. The reason correctly explains the nature of this radical change.

Q3. Assertion (A):

Public enterprises are characterized by public accountability through Parliament.

Reason (R):

Public accountability exists because public enterprises use government employees and are located in government buildings.

Answer: C — A is true but R is false — The assertion is true—public enterprises are accountable to Parliament. However, the reason is false and incomplete. Accountability to Parliament is not primarily because of employee type or building location, but because public funds are invested and the public has a stake in these enterprises.

Unlock more Assertion-Reason questions in Premium — unlock →

Case-Based Questions (CBQ) for Private, Public and Global Enterprises

Case Study:

Rajesh Enterprises operates as a private partnership firm providing legal consultation services in Delhi. Following market liberalization, a large government company called National Legal Services Corporation (NLSC) was established to provide subsidized legal services to economically weaker sections. Simultaneously, multinational legal consulting firms like Clifford Chance opened offices in India. Rajesh's firm faces competition from both the government enterprise and global firms. The government is considering disinvestment of NLSC as it has been incurring losses, while the multinational firms continue to thrive by focusing on corporate clients.

Q1. Which sector does Rajesh Enterprises belong to?

  • A. Public sector
  • B. Private sector ✓
  • C. Government company
  • D. Departmental undertaking

Answer: B

Q2. NLSC can be classified as:

  • A. A departmental undertaking of a ministry
  • B. A multinational corporation
  • C. A statutory corporation or government company ✓
  • D. A partnership firm

Answer: C

Q3. The presence of multinational legal firms like Clifford Chance in India demonstrates:

  • A. The impact of the 1948 Industrial Policy
  • B. The result of 1991 liberalization and foreign direct investment policies ✓
  • C. The failure of private enterprises in India
  • D. The government's preference for global enterprises only

Answer: B

Q4. The government's consideration of NLSC disinvestment reflects which policy trend mentioned in the chapter?

  • A. The 1956 emphasis on public sector importance
  • B. The 1948 Industrial Policy Resolution
  • C. The 1991 shift toward disinvestment and privatization ✓
  • D. Elimination of all government enterprises

Answer: C

Unlock more case studies in Premium — unlock →

Next chapterBusiness Services →
Found this useful? Share it with your class group.

You've seen the free preview. Open the full interactive study kit — mind map, instant-graded quiz, progress tracking — free, no sign-in required.

Open Full Study Kit — Free →

Premium unlocks the full Question Bank, Daily Practice Papers, Chapter Quiz and Full Mock Papers for every chapter.